15 yr-old submits a ‘Holocaust denial’ report called Holohoax, & gets an ‘A’

 

view videoAmerican educator gives an ‘A’ for a report that includes comments like this: “The Germans were against typhus, which was the real reason for shaving heads, fumigating buildings, and cremating corpses.”

By Martin Hill

 

A 15-year-old girl from Southern California who attends a public high school tells the story of how she recently became aware of questions concerning the holocaust. After hearing the establishment’s version of the ‘shoah’ in her history class for weeks along with persistent rumors that Obamacare included provisions for microchipping all Americans, she was very upset at all the frightening and traumatizing details. But then she had an encounter which led her to question what she had been taught, and decided to conduct her own investigation.

Jazzy – YouTube screenshot

Upon completion of her research, she decided to submit a report for a school project in an elective class she was taking for extra credit. She titled it ‘Holohoax,’ and got an A on the report! Unfortunately for the regime, the widely accepted version of the ‘holocaust’ which has been passed down for generations and constantly promoted through Hollywood propaganda films is not enough to brainwash the youth, who are increasingly thinking for themselves, outside the box.

Here is Jazzy’s report as well as a brief video introduction.

(Since many of her YouTube interviews have been deleted, click link to view our copy:)

https://www.israelandstuff.com/wp-content/uploads/2013/05/15-yr-old-girl-gets-an-A-on-Holohoax-report-for-school.mp4

Holohoax

A lie known worldwide, spreading to clueless people and creating disaster everywhere, has caused so many German lives to be spitefully taken. The “Holocaust”, an alleged story of millions of Jews being tortured in concentration camps, has been proven time and time again to be inaccurate, For the acclaimed number of murdered Jews to be true is impossible, proven so not only by logic, but also the fact that the “survivors” of these evens have been known to and even admitted to being paid to lie about it. This in itself should be proof enough of this act of misleading propaganda being false, but there is indeed more evidence.

One reason to believe that the Holocaust is a lie is that the Jews claimed to have been murdered in gas chambers, groups as a time. However, no evidence of such occurrences has been shown or documented. According to scientists who were assigned to study the bodies of the victims of World War 2, “Most of them died from typhus epidemics. Most of the rest of them died from starvation and lack of medical supply care resulting from allied bombing raids against food and medical supply lines. (http://www.urbandictionary.com/define.php?term=holohoax) The Jews show pictures of hair and clothing of women and children, claiming that they were used for soap and rugs after their owners being stripped of them and brutally killed. However, the truth lies in the fact that “The Germans were against typhus, which was the real reason for shaving heads, fumigating buildings, and cremating corpses.” (http://www.urbandictionary.com/define.php?term=holohoax) Also, heads were shaved and people were gathered top be treated not with lethal gases in order to commit genocide, but with repellant, to stop the epidemic of head lice spreading throughout the camps.

Another thing that contradicts the lies of faulty “survivors” is that the number of Jews said to be killed in the camps was inaccurately stated. Six million Jews were supposedly killed in the Holocaust, when not even such an amount existed in Europe entirely, let alone Germany. “In 1939, there were nearly 15,700,000 Jews in the world. After the Second World War that number had risen to over 18,000,000 Jews. What this means is that of the 15,000,000 original Jews on the planet, 6,000,000 were gassed, leaving only some 9,000,000-plus. Then, the world Jewish population rebounded and doubled to over 18,000,000 in less than nine years – an astronomical feat, which astounded biologists and baby doctors everywhere!” (http://exposing-the-holocaust-hoax-archive.blogspot.com/2009/09/fun-facts-holohoax-for-dummies.html) Not only were the Jews not murdered, but were give a choice. “For that we must go back to one Ilea Ehrenburg,* chief Soviet propagandist during the Second World War and later on to die in Israel, who coined the mythic number on Dec. 22, 1944 – BEFORE tens of thousands of Jewish internees, given the choice of staying to be “liberated” by the Communists or going with their German captors, did not hesitate to choose the latter option!” (http://exposing-the-holocaust-hoax-archive.blogspot.com/2009/09/fun-facts-holohoax-for-dummies.html) Thus proving that the Jewish population was not forced to concentration camps to be scalped and gassed.

Not only do we have visible proof of the holocaust being a lie, but also some very trustworthy witness: The American Red Cross. The Red Cross was asked to do an investigation and search of the camps and corpses, and make accurate reports on their findings. “Says the Report: ‘In the chaotic condition of Germany after the invasion during the final months of the war, the camps received no food supplies at all and starvation claimed an increasing number of victims. Itself alarmed by this situation, the German Government at last informed the ICRC on February 1st, 1945 … In March 1945, discussions between the President of the ICRC and General of the S.S. Kaltenbrunner gave even more decisive results. Relief could henceforth be distributed by the ICRC, and one delegate was authorized to stay in each camp …’ (Vol. III, p. 83).” (http://www.ihr.org/books/harwood/dsmrd01.html) In reading this, one may conclude that the Germans did not intentionally kill the Jews, but strove to maintain lives. Many of the allegations against the Germans made by Jews involved gas chambers, which they claimed to be stripped, shaved, and gathered into for a mass killing. However, in order for a gas chamber to exist on a premise, there must be airtight doors and high chimneys, neither of which was found at the former “death camps.” Also, there is no proof of the gassed Jews except for allegations made by hired phony witnesses. According to the Red Cross, “Though six million Jews supposedly died in the gas chambers, not one body has ever been autopsied and found to have died of gas poisoning. We have been shown piles of bodies from World War II, but most of these persons died of typhus or starvation or Allied bombings and a great many of those were murdered Germans – the equivalent of ten football fields should be packed full of gassed bodies to present as evidence, yet not one body has ever been discovered.” (http://www.biblebelievers.org.au/holohoax.htm) If this is not proof enough, what else is needed? What excuse can be made in retort?

This is not to say that the Holocaust did not take place. It is only to prove that it did not happen as it was told according to the Jews. Not only in the camps, but all over the world, people died; suffered from starvation, typhus and bombing raids in World War 2. Lastly, without being given the evidence that it did happen as it is told, we are shown clues that the effects on Europe of World War 2 was much different; not a story that would benefit the Jews, giving them compensation each month for some thing that was simply a hyperbole.

About the Author:

Martin Hill is a Catholic paleoconservative and civil rights advocate. His work has been featured in the Los Angeles Daily News, San Gabriel Valley Tribune, Contra Costa Times, Pasadena Star News, Silicon Valley Mercury News, Long Beach Press Telegram, Inland Valley Daily Bulletin, L.A. Harbor Daily Breeze, Whittier Daily News, LewRockwell.com, WhatReallyHappened, Infowars, PrisonPlanet, Economic Policy Journal, FreedomsPhoenix, Veterans Today, Educate-Yourself.org, The Wayne Madsen Report, Devvy.com, Rense, Antiwar.com, IamtheWitness.com, The Dr. Katherine Albrecht Show, Jonathan Turley blog, National Motorists Association, RomanCatholicReport.com, Republic Broadcasting Network, WorldNetDaily, Dr. Kevin Barret’s Truth Jihad radio show, The Orange County Register, KNBC4 Los Angeles, Los Angeles Catholic Lay Mission Newspaper, KFI 640, The Press Enterprise, Redlands Daily Facts, BlackBoxVoting, Strike-The-Root, David Icke, and many others.

Archives can be found at LibertyFight.com and DontWakeMeUp.Org.

 

Source of original The Rebel publication at: http://therebel.org/history/642232-15-year-old-girl-learns-the-truth-about-the-holohoax-submits-a-report-and-gets-an-a#josc

 

======================================

In Rebuttal:

By Phillip Pasmanick, IsraelandStuff.com

 

In light of the outrageous antisemitic comments appearing below, I wish to make a few personal observations.

First of all, I’ll not fault this child. Although she appears a nitwit, she was being spoon-feed ideas (i.e. YouTube) that apparently she accepted easily as facts. So, seeing how naïve she is, I can only blame her teacher, and school officials for allowing revisionist history to be taught in a public school.

As for the facts being disputed.
The gas chambers did (still do) indeed exist, and can be viewed at Auschwitz (museum). For those who have never been there, yet suggest they were built after the war, please explain the film shown inside the museum, filmed by the Nazis themselves, showing the Jews arriving in cattle-cars, sent to the ‘selection’ stations, entering the undressing room, then entering the ‘showers’ where they were filmed dying a horrible death from the gas.

These were filmed by US Army personnel of the Gas Chambers of Hitler’s DACHAU and other Nazi camps in 1945:
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=c-6CchE1NqI
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ifIFNK8fsEI


One only needs to visit any death-camp to see for yourself this irrefutable evidence.

More proof in this article by the (basically anti-Israel) AP:

SS ‘Accountant of Auschwitz’ going on trial in Germany

Nazi soldier, 93-year-old Oskar Groening, goes on trial for his part in Nazi crimes during Holocaust.

Former ‪‎Nazi‬ guard Groening said he felt an obligation to talk about his past to confront those who deny the ‪‎Holocaust‬. “I want to tell those deniers that I have seen the crematoria, I have seen the burning pits, and I want to assure you that these atrocities happened,” he said. “I was there.”

Read the entire article here: SS Guard, a.k.a. the ‘Accountant of Auschwitz’ goes on trial in Germany

Or find any one of a dozen different sources, via Google search of: ‘Accountant of Auschwitz’

 

The numbers of Jews killed varied and have even been challenged in the European courts when authors were forced to defend their libel & ‘incitement’.
Whereas I hate to use Wikipedia as a source, this article not only makes my point, but THERE you can find the accredited sources as to the revisionist’s lies:
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Holocaust_denial

I do want to expound on the number of ‘6,000,000’. The number seems to have first been mentioned by Dr. Wilhelm Hoettl, an Austrian-born official in the Third Reich and a trained historian who served in a number of senior positions in the SS.

In November 1945, Hoettl testified for the prosecution in the Nuremberg trials of accused Nazi war criminals. Later, in the 1961 trial in Israel of Adolf Eichmann, he also submitted to a lengthy series of questions from the prosecution, speaking under oath from a courtroom in Austria.

On both occasions, he described a conversation he had had with Eichmann, the SS official who had principal responsibility for the logistics of the Jewish genocide, in Budapest in August 1944. In the 1961 testimony, Hoettl recalled how “Eichmann … told me that, according to his information, some 6,000,000 Jews had perished until then — 4,000,000 in extermination camps and the remaining 2,000,000 through shooting by the Operations Units and other causes.”
(The 4,000,000 that died in the extermination camps were not all gassed upon arrival. The total deaths also includes those who died of severe starvation, hypothermia and untreated illnesses, after being transported to the camps.)

One of the earliest researchers, Raul Hilberg, came up with a figure of 5.1 million in his 1961 classic “The Destruction of the European Jews.” In the third edition, from 1985, he provides a lengthy appendix explaining how he calculated the estimate.

Lucy Dawidowicz, in her “The War Against the Jews” (1975), used prewar birth and death records to come up with a more precise figure of 5,933,900. And one of the more authoritative German scholars of the subject, Wolfgang Benz, offered a range of 5.3 to 6.2 million. Each used his or her own method to arrive at the totals.

In conclusion, I must point out that many of the European revisionists have had their ‘evidence’ challenged in courts, only to learn through scrutiny, the ‘new evidence’ being passed around from one delusional anti-Semite to another, was fabricated or simply unsubstantiated. And still, many skeptics are basing their entire arguments on these repeated lies they believe to be true, just because it was published.

All one has to do is go to Auschwitz, as I did. The proof in their museum is in such abundance, you will be unable to question it further, unless, you’re simply blinded by hate, and in that case, I’m just wasting my time.

Unfortunately for the hatemongers, REAL academicians, historians and forensic scientists, will only find evidence to solidify what we already know to be the truth.

Logo Small 2

 

Never Forget Never Again

 

200 comments

  1. This is really sad commentary! No words can accurately describe just how disgusting this whole report truly is!

    • Every Board of Education needs to have guidelines named after this teacher.

      • Lillian mac Isaac. says:

        Are the teacher and student both mentally challenged? I have never heard such fairy tales.

      • Mike Zabby says:

        I will agree this video was not a great one to express the delicate idea that there was no holocaust. But remember, she is only 15. Of course on this site she will be eaten alive by pro-Israel folks. Personally I am only about trying to find the truth about history. Like so many of us, we can only make up our minds based off of what we read and watch because we are not old enough to know first hand. Wars are terrible and there is no doubt too many lives were lost on ALL sides!
        I have watched and read many videos and articles for some time now. It can be difficult for someone neutral to even figure out what to believe when there are 2 sides to a story, both with very passionate voices. I hope you all see I am unbiased.
        Who does control the media? And please explain to me how you come up with 6 million Jews dying in WWII.

        • You ask: Who does control the media?
          Since Western mainstream media is so biasly anti-Israel, as proven in how it’s presented, it’s obviously not controlled by the Jews, who BTW are said to, by neo-Nazi, Aryan and antisemitic groups.
          This interview of a journalist explains how & why the media is bias: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=V5PZYuQ6NBI

          As to your last question: Please explain to me how you come up with 6 million Jews dying in WWII.
          I posted this on the bottom of the post, but here it is again:
          The numbers of Jews killed varied and have even been challenged in the European courts when authors were forced to defend their libel & ‘incitement’.

          The number seems to have first been mentioned by Dr. Wilhelm Hoettl, an Austrian-born official in the Third Reich and a trained historian who served in a number of senior positions in the SS.

          In November 1945, Hoettl testified for the prosecution in the Nuremberg trials of accused Nazi war criminals. Later, in the 1961 trial in Israel of Adolf Eichmann, he also submitted to a lengthy series of questions from the prosecution, speaking under oath from a courtroom in Austria.

          On both occasions, he described a conversation he had had with Eichmann, the SS official who had principal responsibility for the logistics of the Jewish genocide, in Budapest in August 1944. In the 1961 testimony, Hoettl recalled how “Eichmann … told me that, according to his information, some 6,000,000 Jews had perished until then — 4,000,000 in extermination camps and the remaining 2,000,000 through shooting by the Operations Units and other causes, such as disease, etc.”

          One of the earliest researchers, Raul Hilberg, came up with a figure of 5.1 million in his 1961 classic “The Destruction of the European Jews.” In the third edition, from 1985, he provides a lengthy appendix explaining how he calculated the estimate.

          Lucy Dawidowicz, in her “The War Against the Jews” (1975), used prewar birth and death records to come up with a more precise figure of 5,933,900. And one of the more authoritative German scholars of the subject, Wolfgang Benz, offered a range of 5.3 to 6.2 million. Each used his or her own method to arrive at the totals.

          • Bob Smith says:

            l have never seen anything anti Israel in the media, and saying that it is bias “as proven in how it is presented” does not make any sense, it can’t be proven true because it is true….the cup is red as proven by the fact that the cup looks red…?

          • Mr Smith, Had you watched and paid attention to the clip, (biasly anti-Israel) you would have heard an AP reporter being interviewed on CNN articulate in detail how it is biased.

        • Paul says:

          I have family members still alive that grew up in these camps and are a meger percent that are still alive. Their stories are written all over their faces.

          • Timothy Corder says:

            I have a close friend whose parents were czechoslovakian jews who were camp prisoners during WWII. They are both dead now, but survived to raise their small family in Los Angeles. I heard them tell their stories. I saw the pain in their faces as they described watching their parents and brothers and sisters killed before their eyes. While their individual stories do nothing to confirm the numbers, they are all the proof anyone would need to conclude that they were treated with such cruelty, with such inhumanity, that no one hearing them describe their deeply personal experiences could deny that it happened. The terror and anxiety of what they endured continues to trickle down and is evident in their descendants to this day. This student’s grade should ve suspended until she is sent to visit the National Holocaust museum in Washington, D.C. I will volunteer to provide her airfare and accommodations. If she has any heart or conscience whatsoever, the things she will see there will compel her to re-write her misguided essay. There is no other way to teach this child the foolishness and heartlessness of her thinking.

          • Your suggestion is spot-on and your generosity, & humanity, as far as I feel, is appreciated and respected, but alas, the child’s identity wasn’t in the article, nor were the name of her school or imbecilic teacher.

            BTW…My Czechoslovakian born mother, and her sister were both interned in Auschwitz. Sadly, I too am familiar with similar horror stories.

        • Jason Feinman says:

          I guess the testimony from the Nazi soldier himself wasn’t enough for you. Game = Over.

        • Jason Feinman says:

          My late uncle liberated one of the concentration camps. Thankfully, his testimony was recorded for history and is undeniable proof of the Holocaust. http://youtu.be/GDK9owG0lnM

        • Me says:

          You’re a f@$&’n idiot! Look up Yad Vashem. It’ll educate you on the holocaust. I swear some people are just morons.

        • Tal says:

          “pro-Israel folks” , “Who does control the media” , “you come up with 6 million Jews dying in WWII”

          My grandmother’s brother died from drowned ship of immigrants to Palestine. The ship was sunk by a German / Russian submarine (dispute regarding the identity of the submarine) – to who 6 million Jews it belongs? Murdered in the death camps or the Jews who escaped the death camps ?

        • Idan says:

          Mike, Im sorry to say that, I dont know how old are you but Im sure that the reason that you dont really believe or know that 6 million Jews were killed during that distressing war is coming from ignorance.
          I dont blame you but I do blame the education system at your country or your teachers…

        • Stef says:

          Mike

          I feel sorry for you.

          Your response is obviously a sad reflection of both yours and this young girls education.

          All my life i was told to question everything. But i was also taught common sense and the skills to reason.

          It would seem too many of you have niether the skills nor intellect to achieve this … Else are too busy looking for someone else to blame (ie the jews).

          It would seem common sense is not so common

        • binyaa says:

          just the facts ….its called the Truth…

        • I would suggest that you look at the referenced in the rebuttal, her’s are not very reliable. I am truly saddened for this child because of the educator that gave her an “A”. As for the 6 million that died again, look at the rebuttal.

        • Julian Brachfeld says:

          If you even have the slightest doubt about the depth of depravity carried out by the Nazis against not only the Jews, but the handicapped, homosexuals, the Catholics, etc., you need to watch more documentaries. Approximately 20 MILLION lives were taken by those scumbags.
          My father, two aunts, and grandparents managed to escape the Nazi wrath leaving behind 5 uncles who are no longer available for comment.
          I have personally interviewed many survivors and their stories are way too similar to believe for one second that they were all lying.
          Film footage of the liberation of the camps is available as well.
          As it turns out, only Jew haters deny the holocaust.
          To deny the holocaust is to deny your own existence.

          The other 20 million are no longer available for comment either.

      • Mary Powers says:

        Never considered reincarnation as being true until some unexplainable things happened. Just today on Facebook I brought up posts of sirens going off in Israel in honor of those who died in the Holocaust. I began to cry and wondered why it affected me so deeply. I belong to a group on Facebook called I LOVE ISRAEL. I am not Jewish. Have often wondered if I was truly reincarnated from one of Hitler’s victims. I was born in July 1944. I can see the bias about Israel in the news and wonder why more cannot see this or refuse to open their eyes to what is really going on.

    • this is a disgrace to the tacher and student who is so stupid as to try to rewrite history and to present it in this fashion is digusting.

      • John says:

        What is most sad about this essay, forgetting the factual inaccuracy in each paragraph, is the fact any teacher would give it an A. The grammar is horrific. The overuse of the word “that”, the terrible sentence structure, and misuse of commas earn this paper, at the very most, a C.

        Who cares about the hateful vitriol? Furthermore, when the majority of your footnotes point to http://urbandictionary.com there is a serious problem with proving the hypothesis. Come on. Use sources with a little more legitimacy than neo-nazi, ultra-leftwing, and antisemitic agendas.

        • Kathy says:

          I agree, this was like me using Wikipedia in an academic, peer reviewed scientific paper… Urbandictionary is a hoax in itself!

        • Keith Kirkendall says:

          John; I agree that her sources were inaccurate and the essay should have received an F. However, you are inaccurate in including “ultra-leftwing” into the mix. The hate groups like the neo-nazis, KKK, etc. are all right-wing groups who vote republican. My source comes from the Southern Poverty Law Center.

          • phillip says:

            SPLC? Now there’s an unbiased source.

          • CDEvansJr says:

            The Southern Poverty Law Center is a ultra-leftwing group. The KKK was started by democrats after the civil war to control blacks. Just as democrats of today try to do. Neo nazis are in no way Republican. Republicans are for individual freedom & less government control. Neo Nazis are more like muslims & democrats in they believe everyone should be controlled by them.

          • Douglas Houk says:

            Now using the Southern Poverty Law Center for a reliable source is just as bad as Wikipedia or urban dictionary as a reliable reference. This is what constitutes education in the U.S. anymore, these pseudo intellectuals that have shit for brains are indoctrinating these gullible idiotic students into believing crap and trying to rewrite historical facts. That is why Eisenhower ordered that the camps be photographed because he knew shit for brains would try to say this never happened. It is happening right now with Christians in the Middle East from the muzzie bastards that were the allies of the Nazi bastards. Talk about evil bastards flocking together.

          • Timothy Corder says:

            The KKK started with the democrats. They are the racists, the haters of modern times. Leftist ideology is impossible to defend, especially on this topic. Look at them now, trying to shut down free speech, attacking Christians, and trying to repeal the 2nd Amendment. Government infringement on the rights of its people to possess arms was the last step taken as a precursor to the atrocities of Nazi Germany, and is consistently the last step taken by any ruling class just prior to genocide. The left has drifted far from an ideology that represents us or protects our rights.

        • Helice says:

          THANK YOU!!!!! I was shocked that this paper would get an A, even if had been factual, which it was so far from. Seeing that the teacher gave it an A tells me it is aligned with the teacher’s own views. Also, where are the parents? If my children ever wrote a paper stating the Holocaust was a hoax, I would be horrified and I would wonder how I possibly allowed this to happen. This is a 15 year old girl. Her parents have to, at least to some point, have knowledge of her views. Shame on the girl, the teacher, the school system AND ESPECIALLY the parents.

      • Idan says:

        Unfortunately antisemitism around the world is increasing, and becoming more aggressive…
        In our generation we have made it very clear to ourselves, and to the others that want our land, the words NO MORE and NEVER AGAIN will be well heard everywhere!

      • Tabitha says:

        re-writing history is a part of our kids education in the schools today. Textbooks have changed over the years and facts are being omitted or changed. I went a Michigan Department of Education meeting back in November and one of the board members stated, kids are presented information by the teachers and the kids form their own opinions….. So basically a historical date we know as fact isn’t necessarily fact if the kid doesn’t want to believe it. kids doing research are using the internet and we all know information on the internet is not necessarily correct. One site may have true information and another may have information that is not correct, so the kid decides to use the site with the incorrect information and now believes that info to be true.

    • susan says:

      Yes its tragic to try and water down a horrific event like that. I have a friend who survived it as He was a teen and still has the tatoo number on him just more liberal accolades for a young girl with out wisdom. She needs to meet some of the survivors and read the hiding place and Anne Franks diary.

      • CDEvansJr says:

        Exactly. I used to work with a woman who had the tattoo numbers. If this girl ever listen to one of these people tell their story she would know it was true. This woman told of being rescued by allied forces a day before she was to be sterilized. This was in the mid 80s when I talked to her & she still cried like a baby telling the story but would tell it to anyone who would listen.

    • Jim says:

      This twit has never been to Germany, or Poland.

    • r.l. says:

      Go on the youtube video and let her know that she’s a piece of trash!

      • Bane says:

        While outrageous, she is still a 15 year old. The issue here is not just the teacher and student, but the parents. Obviously this young lady has been brought up being taught the wrong way by whatever circle she might be linked into.
        The point I am trying to make is to not bash the girl she is just the apparent collateral of a poor social circle, and that is where the true blame belongs.

        • Victor Portier says:

          Stop giving excuses to every moron. Liberals are pathetic. Hitler was a collateral of his child hood too. So are we to pity him and excuse him of his crimes. If you are born and idiot you will die an idiot. This girl is an idiot to even take up such subject.

    • Nathan says:

      Though I am not Jewish, or even believe in religious mythology, and while I have zero use for Zionists, I must say that denying the FACT of the Holocaust shows how far this nation has fallen due to the constant inundation of far right, fascist propaganda. I know Israeli Jews think the conservatives of America are on their side, but the truth is, while they claim to “love” Israel, they truly despise the Jewish people. Most of the men pulling the strings of the conservative movement are descended from men who supported Hitler and the only reason they pretend to support you now is because it serves their purpose. I myself have no problem with the Jewish people, or the Palestinian people. I do, however, have a huge problem with my tax dollars being sent to Israel in the form of weapons of war that are use to oppress others with. As for the Holocaust, there is no doubt that it happened and that it was one of the worst atrocities of the 20th century, and knowing that there are those in this country who would deny that fact has me very worried about our future. ‘Those who cannot remember the past are condemned to repeat it.’

      • Pro Libertate says:

        Just one little correction: it’s FAR LEFT propaganda!

        The Nazis were 100% LEFT-WING and in fact the leftist MAINSTREAM in the 1920s and 1930s, which is why the European and American media defended them consistently, until they started the war.

        Nazi stands for “Nazional Sozialist”. The full party name was NSDAP, “National Sozialistische Deutsche Arbeiter Partei”. Read their political program (available online) and listen to Hitler’s speeches: he was a raving lunatic and his anti-Capitalist rhetoric sounded exactly like Chavez.

        Modern antisemitic parties are all on the left, e.g. the French Front National, which wants even MORE government and controls than they already have or the far left Jobbik, in Hungary, which receives funding from Iran.

        Contrariwise, Wilders’ party in the Netherlands is classical liberal, supports Capitalism and opposes Islam, but supports Jews and Israel.

        Same is true for SVP/UDC in Switzerland, which is for a small, decentralized government, low taxes and a capitalist economy. They also support Israel and Jews, while the socialists and green party are openly “anti-zionist”, which really just means “dishonest antisemtites”.

        • Papabear says:

          Despite having the word “Socialist” in their name, the Nazis were not a Left, but Right Wing political organization. Specifically, they were a dictatorship with a socialist name. You’ll find tha the Russians and the Germans of the era were at exact opposites of the political spectrum

      • Ben says:

        Everything you say is fine… But those “tax dollars” you miss so much…? Those dollars are saving the world from the scurge of Islamic extremists who would make “9/11” happen every year. Thank goodness that the Israeli army exists today to do the real dirty work that U.S. Army won’t do – and would be criticized if they did – a job the Israeli army does with little regard to people’s disapproval – but for the greater of humanity none-the-less. Be grateful, not regretful.

    • Jimmy Arbelaez says:

      My grandfather pfc RT Reedy with his battalion liberated a concentration camp in Germany WWII. The photographer that was with him shared his camera and photos of the camp and the gas chambers, ovens, etc. We have the copies. This did happen. It is important not to forget these mistakes as no one could confirm what was happening.

    • Lainie says:

      First of all this child cannot write an essay. There are numerous errors. She cites no authorities or sources and shame on the teacher who gave her an A. That teacher wouldn’t know a well written essay, regardless of the facts. She writes poorly. An expository report has nothing to do with her opinion. Sorry I wasted my time. To the writer: stay in school.

    • chris sky says:

      The “Holohoax” the perpetual “victim status” that allows Israel to not only steal money from countries to THIS DAY… but it allows them to perpetuate war crimes with impunity against all it’s neighbors while constantly claiming to be “the victim”

      I have been to Sacsenhausen Concentration camp in Germany. I have studied WW2 in detail. did Jews die in WW2 in Nazi Camps? Hell yes…. but not even close to “6 million” a number that was chosen specifically for propaganda purposes as it’s the “prophecy” of 6 million dying before the Jews coudl return home.. one simply need to type “6 million Jews” in google and see the plethora of headlines DECADES before WW2, beging to save “6 million dead or dying Jews.” It’s 1000% certified bulls*t. hundreds of thousands of jews – maybe 1 million plus were undoubtedly were killed during the war… along with 30 MILLION non jews who arguably died trying to save the Jews! …but only Israel has 39 war crimes Vetoed by the USA to save it from prosecution… only Israel can do airstrikes on Syria without being attacked and claim it’s “Self Defense” only Israel can force countries like Germany to PAY for it’s nuclear submarines as “reparations”… and only ISRAEL can instal DUAL CITIZENS into the US government while at the same time taking BILLIONS per year, and forcing Americans to fight wars in the middle east to satisfy Israel’s “greater Israel” expansion project.

      The Holohoax.. is exactly that. Very carefully scripted propaganda, by the Zionists. it’s quite simple… Hitler got funding from SOMEWHERE (the banks) and WHO OWNED the Banks? The Zionist (fake Jews) who were more than happy to sacrifice REAL Jews to get what they wanted…. ISRAEL. on Palestine Land… and never ending “raparations payments” and never ending “Victim status.”

      nuf said.

    • Elissa S. Aks-Srabstein says:

      Here is a link to Steven Spielberg’s Film and Video Archive, which is part of the United States Holocaust Museum collection.

      https://secure.ushmm.org/online/film/search/result.php?search_type=simple&Query=Concentration+Camp&is_digitized=true&MaxPageDocs=25&StartDoc=26

      Here, one can view movie footage of the concentration camps for themselves.

      The French documentary, Night and Fog (You Tube) is another must see. A person initially is shown explaining that it has been removed, but just wait, because it will come on several seconds later. This was made 10 years after the end of WWII.

      My dearest friend is a 90 year old survivor of 2 concentration camps. Her vivid recounting of her family’s story is in the US Holocaust Museum. I would give her name, but I wish to protect her privacy and safety.

      I only wish that Jazzy could see German archival concentration/death camp film footage, view Night and Fog, etc., meet with survivors, listen to their stories and ask questions of them. It would be interesting to ask her to then write another paper, sharing how her views and understandings changed or stayed the same.

  2. Cheryl Shmilovich says:

    Cheryl Shmilovich · Top Commenter · ESOL Teacher at School District of Philadelphia
    Is this kid a moron? The teacher certainly is, giving her an A. I find this disgraceful and disgusting. Where she got her information, I cannot imagine. She is a fool and all who believe her are worse fools. I am just sickened. I taught Holocaust and have met survivors. Someone needs to educate this twit. And the moron teacher who has encouraged her to do this.
    Reply · Like · Follow Post · 2 seconds ago

    • Agreed! The Teacher should be made infamous for his teaching of History.

      As for the dimwit girl, someone needs to take her to Poland. THAT will educate her guaranteed!

      • Michelle Wayne says:

        I’m a child survivor!!! I lost 90% my family and not to typhus!! I would like to teach this people a think or two and open they eyes, as for this stupid girl definitely not a candidate for collage.Thank God that in the country I live in the children get a proper education as for going to Poland well the murder of innocent people whether they where Jews,gypsies,homosexuals and mentally sick or any other also Christians where murdered in many concentration camps in Germany to, only the concentration camps where build by the German Nazis in Poland not by Polish people and the Germans where helped by Ukrainians, Lithuanians, Hungarians,and Bosnian Muslims with a help of Mufti of Jerusalem they all volunteered to fight and kill for Nazi Germany. This should be told to all the children in the world and yes everybody should organize for schools to go to Auschwitz museum in Poland a place where millions of people of all denominations and mostly Jews where gassed, burnt, murdered, slaved, raped by the people that is hard to cal human.

        • jojo says:

          The way things are going these days, this stupid girl will be offered full ride scholarships to Harvard, Yale and UC Berkley.

          It’s pathetic.

        • CDEvansJr says:

          Thank you.

        • Tara says:

          Just so you know, those that helped the Nazis, did so in the face of death themselves. It was either do ______ or DIE. Do not fault whole nationalities when their lives and the lives of their families were at stake. Not everyone could escape. Then after the war, they still could not get to the US and Stalin sent them to his own form of concentration camps…. to Siberia.

          • Jeanne says:

            Not all did it to avoid death. George Soros is a billionaire who as a 14 year old was sent to live with a Christian Nazi sympathizer who cleared their homes of valuables and turned any Jews hiding from the Nazi’s over to the SS.

            George Soros has always claimed it was the best time of his life, and he had no regrets.

            The man was and is still a Monster, backing such groups as the KKK and pro Zionist groups pushing for a two state Israel. He wants so called Palestinians to have an equal share of Israel land at any cost.

    • Lynn Gorse says:

      As a retired teacher, I agree with everything you say Cheryl. Such is the level of education in this country today. Shameful! I too know survivors who have their tatoos. I went to school with the children of survivors. The proof of the Holocaust is undeniable. The films of the Nazis themselves is proof.

  3. Cecelia Futch says:

    Wow. A teenager who did her own research because she was frightened about Obamacare and microchipping Americans! Who taught her how to do evidence based empirical research? Obviously not the school system. Her sources are holocaust denier websites (and we know how accurate the worldwide web is when it comes to disseminating accurate information. I bet that’s where this gal learned about the microchipping garbage) and urbandictionary???? Are you kidding me? And a “teacher” gave her an “A”! Her work is sloppy at best, and the teacher ought to be fired for allowing such shoddy work. To let this girl not only get away with poor research methodology, but to reward her for it is a sad commentary on the state of our nation’s education system!

    • Cecelia, I agree with every word you wrote.

    • Joshua Skye says:

      We must be careful not to condemn those outside the author of the report. Some teachers grade based purely upon completion of the assignment, not the content or its accuracy. Also, we’ve seen from other instances that disagreeing with the content of a student’s work and therefore refusing it or grading it based upon the disagreement has resulted in attacks upon the teacher. Teaching is often a thankless job, and teachers are often caught between a rock and a hard place. The author of the report is at fault here, not the teacher.

      • Dan Flynn says:

        I see your point, but it isn’t just about whether the teacher disagrees with the content. It is that the content is demonstrably false and a teacher is charged with helping a student learn skills of sifting through information to arrive at empirical truth with standards of evidence.

        • John says:

          When I was in school grammar counted. Not only would I have not received and A for this, the report would have been returned as incomplete until all the horrific grammar errors were corrected.

      • Mitch says:

        It’s unfortunate that teachers don’t have the basic notion of scholarship to require that reports be based on vetted and peer-reviewed sources, not just anything found on the internet. The “Institute for Historic Review” only “reviews” and revises one aspect of history – the Holocaust.

      • Tara says:

        When a person does such a report with research, there are acceptable sources, and I am pretty sure that urban dictionary is NOT one of them… So I fault the teacher not for the content of the paper, but the fact that she accepted those sources as reliable. Also ANY paper or essay should be graded on grammar as well as content. This was not an A paper.

    • Janet says:

      This young lady needs a new teacher and the teacher should be put into a camp. They were terrible and the young lady has no idea what she is talking about. My Grandmother was there.

  4. Gavin says:

    This poor girl needs to be taken on a visit to auschwitz!

  5. David says:

    Ahmadinejad would be so proud , I have no words to describe my disgust !

  6. Yoav says:

    You can report this Blog (Blogger) to Google using this link: http://goo.gl/ZOudd

    • Phillip Pasmanick says:

      Why haven’t it removed?

      It needs to be seen by as many as possible, as an example of what is allowed to be called an education.

      • Eliahu Gal-Or says:

        Thank G-d there are still people who answer your question with their brains, rather than (uneasy) guts… I agree 100% with your own answer and this is how I would have answered it had you not done it first. All the best, and if you are near Mevo Modiin some weekday evening, please drop in. Ask for the Pizza Rebbe.

      • Very pleased this is visual. While some here are critical that holocaust denial is a crime in Europe, we must acknowledge that holocaust denial is not an OPINION to be permitted to a paid professional educator. If she can’t offer source criticism to a student and request another assignment in its place, she is failing to perform and the school administrators need to hold a hearing.

        Former educator.

    • Dee says:

      I am in a conundrum here!
      My youngest child is the grand-daughter of refugees from the war. Her grandmothers property was taken over by the Nazi’s they were given 12 hours to completely remove themselves and could not go back.
      I am aghast that this story is being used to incite aggression towards a 15yo child (that is all she is) at the same time as spouting about how not all information on the internet is accurate people are assuming that this is 100% bona-fide.
      Was it a ‘creative writing’ piece, was the aim to go against her beliefs and this is why she was only able to access crap – for want of a better word – sites?
      I feel there is part of the story missing and without ALL the background information on the essay writer, the teacher & the school I am not prepared to pass judgement.
      I am disgusted with the content and I am disturbed by the amount of hate comments on here.
      IF.. this is something she truly believes is an accurate depiction of the Holocaust then she will need to be taught tolerance as she has a long road to travel before she reaches reality and is able to rectify the karmic damage this piece will have done to her soul.

      • Michael says:

        I could not agree more!

      • William Winkelman says:

        The girl laid an egg, and her “teacher” helped her do it, rewarding her for her shoddy research. This paper will stand as the most embarrassing thing she will have ever done in her life. She knew she was going against prevailing scholarly opinion, but went ahead anyway. She’s getting what the scorn she deserves. Think for a moment how her paper strikes former inmates of those concentration camps and their descendants. Holocaust denial is very distressing to those people, and it is in fact anti-Semitism.

        • Hoekom Jy My Haat says:

          I don’t care what her age is, I hope this follows her throughout her life. I am furious at our educations letting her write this, and publish this, unchallenged and uncorrected. I grew up in The Bronx in the 60s. I knew many Jews with tattoo’d arms. Am I now to believe that they were part of a conspiracy over 70 years in the making…? Shame on her, and even more shame upon her teacher.

  7. Cal says:

    When I was a child growing up in Texas I came to know a wonderful lady, her name was Emma. I would go over to her home once a week with my mower and tend to her lawn. For the daunting task of mowing her lawn she would pay me $5, a bologna sandwich and a glass of real lemonade. One day I notice a tattoo on her arm and asked her about it. Emma, you see, like her late husband Franz, was a survivor. She told me about the experiments she and Franz had undergone, experiments that had stunted their growth at age 12. Emma told me about the bodies, “stacked so high you couldn’t see over them”, she was talking about me, I was 16 at the time and about 5’7″, Emma was 4’8″. She talked about the smell of the burning bodies, every day, so strong that she could still smell them, this was in the late 1960s and she could still not get the smell out of her system. Emma was the first Holocaust survivor I ever met. Since then in the many synagogues that I’ve visited I have met many many more. The Holocaust is real and if anything, it was far more vile than we know.

    The idea that you would give an “A” to a student who provided such a shoddily written essay, one that uses such scholarly sites as http://www.urbandictionary.com, or the clearly biased http://exposing-the-holocaust-hoax-archive.blogspot.com, or the known fraud of http://www.ihr.org, or, my favorite, the Christian hate site, http://www.biblebelievers.org.au, would get an “A” is itself a crime against education. But that she makes her “conclusion” without so much as a mention of sites to the contrary. Not one site that had and opposing view.

    Clearly this “essay”, (calling this an essay is an insult to real research) is one where a conclusion was drawn and then “evidence” found to support the prior conclusion. In my opinion this poor child is undoubtedly the child of an anti-Semite, someone who is so steeped in hatred for the Jewish people that they are blinded by anything that might question their world view, which probably includes the notion that, “The Jews Run the World”; along with the idea that, “The Jews killed Jesus and deserve whatever happens to them!”

    As for me, raised in a Christian sect which also had issues with anti-Semitism, but then once one reads Matthew 23, is it any wonder that Christians hate Jews, why the venerable Jesus was a Jew and he hated Jews too! Never mind that it is far easier to disprove Christianity than it is to disprove the Holocaust, to call this girls work, “scholarship” would be akin to calling an apple a raisin. As for me, I’m with the “…ten men shall take hold, out of all the languages of the nations, shall even take hold of the skirt of him that is a Jew, saying: We will go with you, for we have heard that G-d is with you.'”

    As for me, I reject Jazzy’s prior conclusions and submit the following:

    http://fcit.usf.edu/holocaust/People/liberato.htm
    http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/The_Holocaust
    http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_Holocaust_survivors

  8. Luis Escobar says:

    I believe that this report is obviously wrong, I think the author should have not focused only in jews, but also on Russians, for example, it is said that 22 million Russians where murdered in Dead camps too, because they represented “Comunism”, and how about all the “gays” that were murdered too, and “old men” that were too sick to “serve” and “Black men”?. Jews were not the only ones that suffered persecution, torture and murdered. There are more witnesses on this human kind horror.

    • CuriousDave says:

      This comment exposes the widespread ignorance of the truth. It fais to draw a distinction between two wars that were being fought at the time: the military war of power and conquest between armed men, and the genocide of 60% of European Jews. In fact, the Jews (and also the Roma and Cinti, i.e. thr “Gypsies”) are repeatedly treated as little more than collateral damage of the miltary war – unarmed Jewish men, women, childre and babies who happened to be in the way. While no one doubts that millions of Russian people were brutally killed, few are prepared to acknowledge that the Nazis had no plans to totally exterminate the Russians, and were 60% of them killed? Were 1 million Russians killed by bullets after being force-marched out of ghettoes? Were over 2 million gassed to death? Were thousands of Russians killed by their own countrymne even after WWII was over because, as Russians, they had the nerve to survive forced labor camps and return to their hometowns?

    • Mitch says:

      No, it is not “said” that 22 million Russians were murdered in death camps. Most Russians were killed from bombing, shelling, starvation, and massacres, and while 2 million were used as slave labor in Germany, Russians were not sent to death camps.

      Jews (and Roma) were targeted for complete elimination. The Nazis wanted to conquer Russia, but they wanted to kill every single Jew.

      While 6-8% of the Russian population died during the war, 65-70% of European Jews were killed according to a plan to kill 100%.

  9. Jeff says:

    The gas used was hydrogen Cyanide produced from Zyklon B a pesticide.

    The gas is so poisonous, the area does NOT have to be air tight, as many people have pointed out that the chambers were not. Just inhaling it in small concentrations is fatal. It would normally be used in barns or sheds for fumigating and they won’t be air tight.

    • CuriousDave says:

      Holocaust deniers point out with glee that the volumes of Zyklon B needed to kill insects is far higher than the volumes of gas available in Auschwitz II or in Majdanek. How then, they argue, could there have been enough to kill humans? It took expert toxicologists to point to the truth – which is conveniently never revealed by the deniers – that it requires far LESS Zyklon B to kill humans than insects! This is a typical example of the slick and slimy distortions of truth that the public cannot fairly have the time to unearth.

  10. Paul McDonald says:

    Wow, she got her undeniable information from urbandictionary.com. So 75 words indicating the Holocaust didn’t happen, 75 words, well theres your proof. How dumb are some people, she copies 75 words off a website and gets an A? Only in America. And her video, there was no gas chambers, Oh, then what was that building I stood in, in Poland, Oh yes, it was a gas chamber. But then, she is only 15 and very impressionable, she still has time to learn.

  11. Hans van den Berg says:

    That’s the youth in general today: find out a bunch of stuff (preferable on the internet) and don’t check for yourself. Youth worldwide is so ready for any new world-dictator coming up stage soon. They will follow blindly as they follow blindly Justin Bieber who left disgusting remarks in the guestbook at the Anne Frank house in Amsterdam.

  12. kalte Lokshen says:

    Sadly, if a student nowadays spells his name correctly – he gets an A…

    • Cheryl Shmilovich says:

      Sorry, I have to disagree. I do not know where this student goes to school, but it is, obviously, a place where there is no value put on the truth. I am afraid that you may see that in too many schools these days. However, there are still those of us who teach and who require our students to do much much more than spell their names correctly in order to receive an A. I do not only blame the student, who should have double checked and triple checked her information before writing an essay full of lies. I also blame the teacher whom I consider to be either a moron or an anti semite. The teacher should have known better, as should anyone who has done any reading on 20th century history. I was born in 1945 and spent 15 years teaching the Holocaust. My grandmother’s extended family lies in the grave that is Babi Yar. I would be delighted to educate the moron teacher and his/her clueless student. I have done the research, I have met survivors. I have no time, patience, or tolerance for holocaust deniers. I am forced to listen to the news of what the Muslims are doing to the Christians in Africa, and I agree that it is a disgrace. No one, however, has mentioned the centuries during which the Jewish community was blamed for just about any and everything that happened that the Christians were not happy with. Jews were murdered then, for no good reason. No one seems to remember that. Do not deny our history. And, if you don’t like us, then please, do not innoculate you children against polio, don’t avail yourself of anything developed by Jews, don’t read the books written by Jews or listen to the music composed by Jews, stay away from all we have developed (and that means FB, too) and see what you think of the world without Jews.

  13. ms.cracker says:

    This girl should be taught about primary sources. Any time wikipedia comes up on a student paper I’m forced to explain how for 5 years an article about an entirely fictitious war was on wikipedia, but she didn’t even go there! Urbandictionary???? This is a source for RESEARCH???? Last time I wrote a paper on the Holocaust was a long time ago, but I had to look in real books, at copies of documents, and so forth. I, too, have met survivors, and part of my teacher training involved a presentation about the Holocaust also. Not all teachers are this stupid as this girl’s. Isn’t California also having students learn islam in public schools? That might explain more where the teacher is coming from on giving an A for such shoddy work. If there’s a collection to send her on a field trip to Poland, I’ll donate to it. She needs to see not everything on the internet is true.

  14. Max van der Glas says:

    About the Author:

    Martin Hill is a Catholic paleoconservative and civil rights advocate.

    Who wrote this,the girl or as is stated under the article Martin Hill ?? Anyway its discusting !!

  15. Felicia Azut says:

    I am so angered by this story by the teacher and by the idiotic statements this 15 year old girl has to say. Not only did I grow up hearing stories from survivors but my father’s two cousins were the only two to make it out of Auschwitz from the 52 that were deported there from Hungary. I don’t know what to say anymore soon all the survivors will be gone. I have told my children over and over remember one day you will be old and to tell the stories you have heard and that you saw numbers on your cousins arm and never to forget. Shame on the school board for allowing this child to get an A. Shame on them, I moved to Israel 11 years ago next year my oldest daughter will visit Auschwitz on her senior year high school trip. I will make sure to educate as many people as I can so idiots like this won’t be heard.

  16. Moreyn Kamenir says:

    This child is mistaken. She has been indoctrinated and doesn’t even know it. The author however could have refrained from his own admission of: “Unfortunately for the regime, the widely accepted version of the ‘holocaust’ which has been passed down for generations and constantly promoted through Hollywood propaganda films is not enough to brainwash the youth, who are increasingly thinking for themselves, outside the box.”

    • So right….but I don’t know if it was the ‘author’. Maybe just the cameraman. But, either way, I can help but think it was his influence that edged her on. THAT same ‘morality’, probably talked the dimwit into doing a lot more too.

  17. richard says:

    LADY YOU NEED YOUR BRAIN EXAMINED WHAT THE HELL IS THIS?! ARE PEOPLE SO FORGONE NOWADAYS?! SOMEONE PLEASE GIVE AN ANSWER.
    MY FAMILY PERISHED IS IT A LIE?

  18. Mh says:

    Christians do not hate Jews. Christians love Jews and Israel and are their defenders…and died for hiding them. Watch the film ‘The Hiding Place’. Secularists hate Israel and Christians because they imagine a secular eutopia and hate faith…except that of those they imagine to be oppressed minorities like Mulims…they should look a bit closer. ..Islam is an oppressive religion…the freedoms they enjoy are in christian nations.

  19. Teresa Ricci says:

    There is so much information on the Holocaust. She needs to see actual footage of people being marched up to the holes, shots point blank and falling into the pits. A series on PBS is an excellent example of what happened.

  20. rrr#3shalom says:

    She will fit in well with Obama’s cabinet.

  21. Yaja Boren says:

    My name is Yaja
    I am a holocaust survivor of 5 concentration camps one of which was Auschwitz. I was a preteen when I lost all my relatives, more than “50” to Triblinka and Auschwitz gas chambers. Half way through writing my autobiography: “We only have each other”- my keyboard was wet with my tears and couldn’t continue until I finished a novel “There are no strangers.” I than finished and published “We only have each other.” For many years I have been telling my story and selling We only have each other to kids and adults in High schools and Colleges in California. I have never run into a single teacher who would tolerate such ignorance. much less rewarding someone with an “A” for writing lies that someone filled her empty head with. Although I’m very angry that such ignorance still exists, especially in the Catholic Church? I have told my story in Churches and Catholic schools and found the kids to be smart, loving and not a hint of antisemitism. I feel very sorry that a 15 year old girl privileged in growing up in this wonderful USA and not taking advantage of learning truth instead of fiction. It seems to me that this teacher who gave this girl an A for this unbelievable story needs to stop teaching and go back to school and start in first grade.

    • Pro Libertate says:

      I am truly amazed that you managed to get your life back, after those horrors.

      My deepest respect to you!

    • Ralph Sloan says:

      first let me say that I am not of the Jewish faith, even though I worship a Jew. My Mothers birth father was KIA in Italy during WWII, her mother (my Grandmother) remaried to James Dean Marquart who served under Patton. his unit Liberated a sub camp called Mittle bau Dora(sp) it was a V2 rocket plant/ concentration camp. he told us the story of how they walked in on end of a baracks and saw 3men in a bunk and one was dead and it went on till they exited the baracks where they had to strip down naked and throw there clothes in a fire pit and get deloused. he said there must have been thousands of bodies stacked up outside. I could go on but I think people can get the picture. this man had NO reason to lie. I don’t know why I’m commenting as I usualy don’t comment online. but I guess I feel a truth needs to be told.

  22. davida vakachi says:

    What can one say, I’m offended for all those survivors that have to see this and their families, I’m disappointed by any of the so called educators that accepted this pitiful example of a paper, and I feel that a wake up call should be made on the school by the bureau of education, and can only hope that this kind of ridiculous work is a rare example of what children are learning today, since the last of the survivors will not be around soon to explain and give proof of what was, leaving only those who studied of this horrid time period to keep it alive.

    • Ariana says:

      It proves that false things can be found all over the internet and that when a child does research , she/he needs to know that false things exist out in the world and on the internet. Therefore children need to learn they must not believe all that they are reading there is a way to actually find sources that have a connection to the topic you are studying!! Her sources were all Antisemitic including the RED CROSS who most recently showed it’s true colors. It’s sad that in today’s world children are exposed to lies in what they read. The survivors of this horrible time period deserve a public apology by this girl and the teacher needs to be fired for giving an A to a student who made a report on research from antisemitic sources and lairs that want to pretend these things never happened. I feel sorry for the girl actually because she had no idea that she was reading lies. And that in itself is very scary!!!

  23. C B USHER says:

    Do you know, has anyone reported this teacher to their local Education Board ?

    • I don’t know. But, I hope someone did. The teacher who gave her the ‘A’ is THE monster for advancing lies that lead to hate and ignorance.

      • Bill Skirnir says:

        Martin… I haven’t read ALL of the comments yet, but I have come across many jaw-droppingly stupid comments from YOU alone. As a supposed academic and renowned journalist, you are not exactly impartial or objective. This comment needed some response.
        I strongly suspect the teacher that gave her this ‘A’ cringed as they read the report too. But then, marks/grades most likely weren’t given for the content of the report; rather for the effort she put in to research the subject, and the lengthy and fairly concise (for a 15 year old) report. And let’s be honest, if I were a teacher, and I saw every other student enter a report entitled “my holiday” or “my weekend with grandma” or other such inane bull**it, I’d have given this student an ‘A’ too!
        So reporting the teacher would be just pure spite and ill-informed. And “lies that lead to hate and ignorance”??? Come on… anyone can see the hysteria that this emotive issue has spurned from all quarters and all ages of people. There ARE two sides to EVERY story – regardless of whether 99% of the world believe one side!

        • Indeed there are two sides. But western academia acknowledge the conclusions of WWII that was matricusly documented by ICRC, U.S. Army, under direct orders by Gen. Eisenhower to “photograph everything!”, and even the Russians who only became an ally to defeat a common threat.

          Those who advance a ‘counter-theory’ or revisionist history have an agenda, such as the Arabs (as a collective, i.e. Lebanon’s gov’t and/or the Palestinian Authority that included Arab Christians), who prefer to direct sympathies towards the Palestinians, or neo-Nazis who are rotten with antisemitism.

          Any student, doing a paper on why the Earth is really flat, and any contrary opinion is given by a victim of mass hysteria or mass-induced LSD by ‘the powers that rule the world’, had gotten an ‘A’ from it’s teacher, should receive the EXACT SAME Criticism,….for failure to educate, and allowing a student to advance a lie that propagates ignorance.
          Such a teacher should be canned immediately, since as an educator, he (proved) is not!

          • Please apologize for the Arab comment, I am a Christian Arab, Support Israel and denounce this article. I am Highly offended by this racist remark. Get it right the Arabs are not the issue it is the Muslim Arabs.I will be looking for you apology.

          • Since my comment wasn’t clear (it’s been amended as of now) when you commented, I sincerely regret offending you, or other Christian Arabs that took offense. Your support is appreciated and not taken for granted. Many like myself, are doing what we can to assist Israeli Christian Arabs find their own identity, and support their desire to not be automatically integrated into the larger Muslim community.

            Unfortunately, most Christian Arabs have adopted the policies of their Muslim ‘cousins’ in their fight against Israel, and in part, against the Jews. In Lebanon, George Habash, founder of the PFLP spent decades, with fellow Christian Arabs, in his war against the Jews.

            Today, Palestinian Council Member Hanan Ashrawi still publicly demonizes and delegitimizes Israel at every opportunity, as well as many of her colleagues living in Palestinian controlled Bethlehem. So you can see, those Arabs that attack Jews, are not restricted to only the Muslim Arabs.

            Of course, they are not you, or many like you. To you ALL, I pray for your good health & safety, and hope my comment doesn’t diminish your welcomed and appreciated support.

  24. Finkle Stein says:

    Put your shirt back on and then STFU you annoying Schmendrick!

  25. Nicole w says:

    Screw the negative people on here! I say right on sister! Some people choose not to believe every little piece of bs the government likes to feed down our sheep throats…. And what’s more sad we allow them! And here we have a teenage girl with more sense than half of America today. I own encyclopedias from the 1950s that say things ENTIRELY different about the holocaust than what the sensationalized romanticized dramatized Hollywood media says today… Funny how 60 years will automatically make supposed facts grow and change into a mountain from a molehill. And yes!!!! Do visit Auschwitz!!!! Guess what the plaque there says? “1 million Jews died here in the holocaust “. Even the Red Cross has stated that 6 million is an extremely exaggerated number . And what are you guys doing attacking a CHILD over the Internet you fools?

    • Excuse me??!!! “Even the Red Cross has stated that 6 million is an extremely exaggerated number.”

      The number seems to have first been mentioned by Dr. Wilhelm Hoettl, an Austrian-born official in the Third Reich and a trained historian who served in a number of senior positions in the SS.

      In November 1945, Hoettl testified for the prosecution in the Nuremberg trials of accused Nazi war criminals. Later, in the 1961 trial in Israel of Adolf Eichmann, he also submitted to a lengthy series of questions from the prosecution, speaking under oath from a courtroom in Austria.

      On both occasions, he described a conversation he had had with Eichmann, the SS official who had principal responsibility for the logistics of the Jewish genocide, in Budapest in August 1944. In the 1961 testimony, Hoettl recalled how “Eichmann … told me that, according to his information, some 6,000,000 Jews had perished until then — 4,000,000 in extermination camps and the remaining 2,000,000 through shooting by the Operations Units and other causes, such as disease, etc.”

      One of the earliest researchers, Raul Hilberg, came up with a figure of 5.1 million in his 1961 classic “The Destruction of the European Jews.” In the third edition, from 1985, he provides a lengthy appendix explaining how he calculated the estimate.

      Lucy Dawidowicz, in her “The War Against the Jews” (1975), used prewar birth and death records to come up with a more precise figure of 5,933,900. And one of the more authoritative German scholars of the subject, Wolfgang Benz, offered a range of 5.3 to 6.2 million. Each used his or her own method to arrive at the totals.

    • sami goldstein says:

      its not just the death camps that killed millions of jews. auschwitz killed 1million but there were many many death camps and before that they were getting jewish,gypsies and anyone that was different to dig there own pit before they killed them and they aren’t documented. I think u should do ur research before saying these things and same with the girl who wrote this horrible article.

  26. Andrea Iacono says:

    This is ridiculous this youngster American can not possibly know what people went through in ww11 and she can’t possibly think that she can rewrite history

  27. Heather says:

    Wow! This girl did some serious research! And asked some tough questions! I give her a lot of credit for learning beyond the narrow scope of American curriculums. Bravo for the graver for giving her an A. Regardless of what really happened, she makes a solid argument. And she makes very valid points. And you can’t say this girls report holds no truth just because you’ve always been told a different story of the holocaust. Instead of believing what she was told, she took it upon herself to investigate, and for that she is much smarter than many adults. If you disagree with her because you investigated the holocaust, and all theories, and came to a different conclusion, than share your arguments and that’s understandable. But If you disagree with her report because it’s not what you were taught, then don’t bother commenting, because no one likes to hear from a programmed robot.

    • Linda Richman says:

      There is no argument and there are no sides. The Holocaust is historical fact. Those who say that it did not happen are choosing to believe poisonous lies which conform to their anti-Semitic world view.
      The piles of bodies need not explain themselves. The elderly survivors among us are haunted by unspeakable memories. To deny these truths is unspeakably vile.

      • Jon says:

        Meh…even given the veracity of the Holocaust, I can show you ridiculous accounts that are clear fabrications. Roller-coasters into the ovens, anyone? These endemic falsehoods give credence to Holocaust denier positions, and Jews do nothing to refute them. How long did the lampshade nonsense continue? If you cosign a lie, don’t be surprised when the truth suffers.

    • Anonymous says:

      This girl’s report holds no truth because if you look at the sources she used, you’ll realize that none of them are reliable. She used blogs and urban dictionary, which is a satirical dictionary for slang words. This girl is, quite frankly, an anti Semitic idiot and did not give any valid points whatsoever.

    • Please apologize for the Arab comment, I am a Christian Arab, Support Israel and denounce this article. I am Highly offended by this racist remark. Get it right the Arabs are not the issue it is the Muslim Arabs.I will be looking for you apology.

    • Kevin says:

      Heather, with your logic, when I read that you were born without a brain and exist in defiance of all scientific bounds, I should be applauded for doing my own research. So hurray for me for drawing my own conclusions and doing my own research. And when you try to explain how wrong I am, I’ll just use your logic that “well there’s two sides of the story.”

  28. Rollin Shultz says:

    The 15 yr old has the excuse of youth and inexperience on her side, but the many commenters who think Free Speech is a convenience, and should be suspended when you disagree with someone that is inexcusable. She has the right to tell the truth, half truths, or even outright lies if she wants. We can’t pick and choose when it comes to the Constitution, it’s all or nothing.

    Being that grading should not be about content, the grade should have been lower for several misspellings, grammar difficulties, and lack of references.

    • Letting someone believe that the Holocaust did not happen Is wrong and the teacher who gave the A should be fired. Distorting historical fact is fine under the first amendment, but so is saying that it is wrong, untrue , poorly researched and as you pointed out full of grammatical and spelling eras.

  29. Paula Roscoe says:

    I hear the anger and insults from what this CHILD did and it saddens me on all accounts. She does not represent the majority of CHILDREN who have actually learned their history, thank goodness. Whoever taught this girl should feel shame. I feel such sorrow for the girl who has not questioned what has been told. She will learn from this i’m sure x

  30. sam feldstein says:

    I see an obvious grammar mistake: “but were give a choice” and she got an A?! Okay, that’s when you know something is wrong with the teacher here.

  31. moise says:

    The vitriolic and hateful comments to this young student’s essay are if anything counterproductive. If you really want to persuade thoughtful people that there is merit to your point of view you will have to calm down and present some real evidence in place of frantic unsubstantiated opinions. By real evidence I don’t mean the anecdotal hearsay of those who conveniently remember some extraordinary, normally unforgettable, phenomenon some 20-30 or more years after they can be cross examined. Real evidence consists of autopsy and forensic reports or contemporaneous German documents unambiguously referring to gas chambers, such as building plans, a budget, a sequence of orders to carry out homicidal gassings.

    • Phillip Pasmanick says:

      Agreed. Having been to Auschwitz, I saw all that. There is on the death-camp a museum with enough substantiated proof, any intelligent skeptic would be forced to accept.
      After a delegation of Palestinian academics & university students returned to the mid-East, completely convinced after seeing all the irrefutable evidence, Hamas officials laid down the law, forbidding Palestinians from visiting in the future.

      When confronted with train records, death records, and viewing films made by Nazis themselves that were obviously filmed in the very ‘death-showers’ you saw with your own eyes, it’s hard to ignore the hundreds of other bits of proof.

  32. Jim says:

    Jazzy should be commended for swimming against the tide of misinformation. While atrocities were obviously committed, the numbers were grossly exaggerated. Most died from starvation, exposure, and disease–this was exacerbated by the allied bombing campaign. For even having legitimate questions, one is labeled a “holocaust denier” by those who wish to promote the ‘official narrative.’

    • No Jim, those people are not considered a “holocaust denier”. They’re considered as knuckleheads….or just fuckin morons. Why?…because had the Nazis NOT stripped them of ALL possessions, passed laws to punish anyone hiring or dealing with a Jew, or marrying one, had they not rounded up the Jews and quarantined them in walled ghettos before transporting them in cattle cars….standing up for days since they were packed in so tightly….to death camps….ALL without providing the minimum sustenance to support life, THEY WOULD NOT HAVE DIED of “starvation, exposure, and disease”….as you put it!!

      BTW… if all those millions of Jews died as you said…”by the allied bombing campaign”, why didn’t that effect any of the Germans, or Nazis, or Nazi supporters in Western & Central Europe…..where all the death camps were?

    • Jeff says:

      Excuse me Jim but those who died from starvation as unintended consequences of supply lines being destroyed, are still victim of war and are still deaths, therefore considered murdered and victims of war crimes. Those deaths still fall on the heads of the war mongers. They are nodifferent than those gassed.

  33. Drew says:

    I have no proof that the holocaust happened or didn’t happen. What offends me is that people aren’t allowed to research what really did happen. What truth can’t except a challenge? Lies can’t except a challenge. I’ve read of areas where bodies where buried, but that ground penetrating radar show undisturbed soil. I’ve seen blueprints for the crematoria. It had 3 ovens. I’ve seen on tv where the researches can’t find remains of poison gas in the showers, but found lots in the area for delousing clothes. I’ve seen what passes for photocopies of the International Red Cross reports of no wrong doing in the camps. The winners write history, not the losers. Why can’t there be solid research done? If it’s all true, the deniers will have to shut up and go home. But no, researchers are put in prisons.

    • Phillip Pasmanick says:

      Drew, most all of your skepticism seems to be based on blogs or openly antisemitic websites. Too bad you’re unable to produce a single university, government or museum to back any of your comments.
      You wrote, “The winners write history, not the losers.”…but it’s Germany who’s the harshest in punishing those who refute the truth from the German ‘version’…which BTW based on German evidence, is identical to the US version….based on American evidence collected by orders of Gen. Eisenhower….who not only ordered the Army to photograph and document EVERYTHING, he sent communications to both Washington and London, urging the two governments to send instantly to Germany a random group of newspaper editors and representative groups from the national legislatures to do the SAME.

      BTW, Russia also recognizes the truth of the Holocaust, and just legislated laws (March 2014) forbidding its denial or revisionist testimony since it’s now becoming popular due to the propagation of antisemitism throughout the internet.

      Although I rarely use Wikipedia as a source, I suggest you read this: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Holocaust_denial

      • Drew says:

        Sorry for being a skeptic, but really, I can’t even prove that Europe exists. (But I do except that it does). I do read a lot of varied news, and catch documentaries when i can. I have even read a site by a Jew who doesn’t like the barrier to holocaust research.
        Obviously, there are questions about what happened, as I think there should be. It was a major event. Usually there are 2 sides to every story, instead of 1 side and not allowing the other side even if there is some evidence for it.
        I’ll say it again, that truth doesn’t need research restrictions. Free research would settle the matter, whether for or against any ones views. I can’t think of an example where research restrictions were beneficial, in any field.

        • But that’s my point too. The research was totally documented in real-time by many, many governments, who now all have museums displaying the proof.

          Had you read the Wikipedia link above, you would have read how revisionists have challenged the evidence in courts, only to learn through scrutiny, the ‘new evidence’ being passed around from one delusional anti-Semite to another, was fabricated or simply unsubstantiated. And still, many skeptics are basing their entire arguments on these repeated lies they believe are true.

          Sir, all you have to do is go to Auschwitz, as I did. The proof in their museum is in such abundance, you will be unable to question it further, unless, you’re simply blinded by hate, and in that case, I’m just wasting my time.

          BTW, you made a comment earlier: “I’ve read of areas where bodies where buried, but that ground penetrating radar show undisturbed soil.”

          You need to read this: Treblinka gas chambers & mass graves discovered by high-tech archaeologists
          I find it hard to believe the Smithsonian would spend so much to only ‘confirm’ what we already know, when they could become renowned once again, by simply substantiating the revisionist version. Unfortunately for the hatemongers, REAL scientists, will only find evidence to solidify what we already know to be the truth.

          • Drew says:

            Here’s an article i ran across yesterday.
            http://www.presstv.ir/detail/2014/04/14/358475/ww2-revisionism-menacing-zionists/
            The Jews telling me it’s all true sounds like the tobacco companies telling me i need to smoke.
            But you’re not wasting your time. I will continue to read and question.

          • I have addressed each of your points, and you declined to respond. I’ve given you credible links, again you chose not to respond.

            lol….Now, you present an article from the Iranian state run media (that has zero credibility for accurate journalism, but, will publish anything that demonizes Jews & Israel), and you think it’s factual?

            Sorry, if I just end this 2-step we’ve been doing with a sad laugh. We’re finished. I’ll not continue when you back up claims from sources who chant “Death to the Jews, Death to Israel, Death to America” and swear to destroy Israel.

            Be well, and I pray one day you’ll be wiser.

    • Venice mentor says:

      Drew – lack of exposure, knowledge and research usually generate the type of mindset people like you and this young woman.

      https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=KSrRWhhiigM

      I am sure you will say this was all photoshopped. God help us all from the likes of you and the rest of the deniers in this world. BTW, how old are you, 12?

  34. Robert Shapiro says:

    I would sell the girl to Isis…lol

  35. The teacher should be sacked. Not suspended, sacked. His position is worse than the girl’s. He gives an ‘A’ to a report based on the weakest possible sources and does not detract points for her doing so. But neither he nor anyone else has bothered to teach a young girl how to research a subject, how to locate and use genuine sources, how to distinguished academic research from internet ignorance. It’s not really her fault. Lacking the skills to do proper research, yet allowed to work on her own, she has done what too many young people do (and I have encountered far too many at university level), which is to use anything that pops up on internet sites. If she discovered one denial site, she will then have started Googling things like ‘Holocaust denial’ or ‘Holocaust hoax’, taken them at face value, and uased them without balancing material from elsewhere. It’s not her fault. She’s just 15 and has not been properly educated. I have watched videos of American university students who don’t know when the Second World War took place, who have never heard of the Holocaust, and who, in general, have the haziest knowledge of history, politics, religion or anything else. They are the next generation. God preserve us. And the teacher should never be allowed to teach more vulnerable children.

  36. Frank Adam says:

    Foul language is not going to clear up the misunderstandings of the youngster and the incompetence of the teacher.
    It was discovered almost by chance in French North Africa a the beginning of the late century that you could control and prevent typhus which is vectored by lice by shaving the patients’ bodies and fumigation was recognised public health measure with sulphur candles – but not with pest killer known lethal cyanide compounds. Body disposal by mass cremation goes back to the Romans and Greeks after battles.
    The whole is an odd mix of the misuse of truths and incorporation of lies without questioning them; and proof that it is difficult to learn how to identify the context and the premises and assumptions of an event or text.
    The student was right Jews being imprisoned but not about why? Right about the public health justifications for shaving, and cremation but not about why these prisoners were dead in such large numbers? Wrong about the Jewish population figures – pushing up to 18 million in the late 1930’s but never passing 14 million since 1945.
    Her teacher was at fault for not requiring cited sources (by page numbers)and not checking on the reliability of the source authors, alternatively failing to ask why the student thought them believable, or close questioning about the nature of the “gas” or the evidence of allegedly paid witness, when the standard version of the Holocaust is dependent on the evidence of the Nuremburg (and Eichman ) trials.
    This is a disgraceful incident but some of the critics need to brush up their act too.

  37. Steve Edelman says:

    Would someone please find the video evidence of the opening of German records? I know for a fact that Germans were obsessive-compulsive record keepers. Paper records of the Holocaust have been discovered deep underground in Germany. These records document every death in the camps and confirm the numbers. This child has been deceived. She needs to be taken to the archives where she can see the records. She has to count the names one by one, and not leave until she is done. I recommend that her food consist of the potato “soup” eaten by some “lucky” victims once per day while they were at the camps.

  38. Michelle says:

    Mendel and Freeda forkowitz my great grandparents were both killed by hitler you dumbfounded stupid schmuck

  39. Michelle says:

    You are simply dumbfounded stupid and so is your teacher my great grandparents were freeda and Mendel forkowitz they were murdered by hitler

  40. anthony olejniczak says:

    The “Student” wasn’t really a student. She and the guy behind the camera and she cooked the thing up. What school was it? What teacher?

  41. d says:

    This teacher and student need to be reported to UJA. The teacher should be fired for rewarding anti-Semitism and the student needs to be made to understand that there is zero tolerance for anti-Semitism and consequences for failure to perform research. A simple search on youtube will reveal several accounts of this atrocity to humanity.

    Holocaust Uncovered (1945) – WARNING: Distressing Images
    https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=-tGwjwK9pIM

  42. Jan says:

    “A 15-year-old girl from Southern California who attends a public high school tells the story of how she recently became aware of questions concerning the holocaust. After hearing the establishment’s version of the ‘shoah’ in her history class for weeks along with persistent rumors that Obamacare included provisions for microchipping all Americans, she was very upset at all the frightening and traumatizing details. But then she had an encounter which led her to question what she had been taught, and decided to conduct her own investigation.”

    I think the essay is poorly written and certainly doesn’t deserve an “A”, and the teacher made a bad decision to mark it so. It would seem that the teacher didn’t bother to correct the shocking errors, in both language and facts. Time spent researching counts for little when multiple errors result.

    The last line in the first paragraph, “But then she had an encounter . . . “, leads me to ask, what was the encounter that made her question what she’d been taught? Why has no one picked up on that – I’ve haven’t read all the comments and perhaps someone has picked up on it!

    I pity the girl and hope that she learns the truth before much longer.

  43. Mathew says:

    This report is absolutely disgusting! Someone needs to set this girl straight and tell her the truth!

  44. Venice mentor says:

    This young woman and all those like her should be just as well versed on this as the BS they obviously are. Shame on her teacher, shame on her and God save us all from monsters like them.

    https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=dcXAPRe17Ms

  45. Tal Algom says:

    Although this report is 2 years old the issue is eternal. It is ashame to see people in the 21st century, especially young ones, having that much little information of what was and still is, last century’s most shameful 10 years in the history of humanity. As simple as going to a public library, or looking up for information in the right places could have make the difference. There are newspapers, film and photography archives that must have been used by this young girl should the teacher had pointed them to her. But the main problem is the lack of information the teacher has. Well, there’s nothing else to say except, shame shame shame..

  46. may says:

    I invite this idiot to come and read her article,to my parents, both of of them are Holocaust survivors.

  47. Miriam Brukhis says:

    Whoever decided to give this girl an essay is probably incompetent themselves because if they saw the sources she used in her paper, they’re completely unreliable. Urban dictionary is a joke, getting “evidence” from someone’s blog is completely subjective, and if you’re trying to disprove factual historical information, don’t use the bible!!!!! What does the bible know about the holocaust! If you were Christian you weren’t persecuted unless you got yourself involved!

  48. Tal Algom says:

    And again and again and over again..!! Every time there’s an article like this it all turn to be a xenophobic, antisemitic discussion… It is absolutely amazing to see all the hate and envy pouring out of the letters.. I rest my case, make your own conclusions.

  49. Nan says:

    Clearly both idiots. The low level of intelligence of the interviewer, and his force feeding her comments is sickening. The girl has such a poor education, and speaks so poorly. It’s no wonder she doesn’t understand history. The classic example of dumbing down America. One of my college professors had a tatoo on her arm from Aushwitz. This sickens me.

  50. T says:

    “Jazzy’s” “paper” was obviously not graded on any heretofore generally-accepted academic merit.

  51. Bob Packham says:

    This is a despicable story if true. I think this is an urban legend and actually happened in someone’s mind..AAnd did not6happin fact. Someone prove me wrong

  52. Sammy Merzel says:

    This is absolutely mind-blowing. “Scientists believe…” ⬅️ what the hell is this??? Scientists know NOTHING about the Holocaust, especially the consequences. Then again, this was turned in to a teacher in public school, indicating that they have no knowledge of Jewish history whatsoever. But what they DO know is that the Holocaust really did happen, and it was no lie. This girl needs to be taught a lesson.
    Also, one question: did she show this to her parents? Because if she did, she’d be in MAJOR trouble, which she deserves. Denying that it happened is one thing, but going further and explaining why it happened is a one-way trip to Olam Hazeh.

  53. Phil Fink says:

    It is indeed sad that we now depend upon the Internet to teach our children… and what is more pathetic is that teachers who are so uninformed about the Holocaust are allowed to teach revisionism. It is obvious that this young lady has never met a Jew or the relative of a survivor. The gas chambers did and still do exist. children of survivors have had to live with a parent sharing the horrors of the war… PLEASE get this girl an education. Show her the numbers on the arms of those who were in the camps and heard the cries of children and their parents going to their deaths.

    To me it is appalling that the teacher rewarded the student with an A she should lose her teaching certificate and be made to reevaluate her education in the horrific time during Word War Two. I see the survivors each week coming to services at my synagogue… years ago there we mostly survivors who came those who lost their parents and grandparents in the war… today that number is dwindling due to old age.

    Don’t try and rewrite the truth as those who do know what happened say NEVER Again!

  54. nisa says:

    can someone please sponsor a trip for her to auschwitz? this is so sad…I am the grandaughter and daughter of survivors…its all true and will only happen again if naive ideas like this spread

  55. Dina W. says:

    I think this youngster and maybe even the teacher,should make a trip to Poland and see for themselves that although we all wish the Holocoust would be a lie,it really happened,and it was hell forthose who died as well as for those who survived.

  56. Dan says:

    Apparently a 93 year old Nazi guard who is about to go on trial for his role in the Holocaust denys the deniers….

    “I want to tell those deniers that I have seen the crematoria, I have seen the burning pits, and I want to assure you that these atrocities happened,” he said. “I was there.”

    http://www.ynetnews.com/articles/0,7340,L-4648910,00.html

  57. Earl Hamdon says:

    Look, the bottom line is, whether or not the numbers are accurate, whether or not the died of gas, disease, starvation, etc. people still died in these camps. It happened. Dispute the methods and statistics all you like the end result is still the same.
    As far as debating war atrocities or pointing out that the allies committed them as well, it is war. What do you think is going to happen when the beat in man is free to run unfettered? I will say this, the willingness to follow blindly is exactly what will allow this to happen in our country and soon. Good for the girl for questioning history. You may not like what her conclusion was but at least she bothered to think instead of just accepting what she was told. Fear and blind acceptance is what allowed the Nazis to do what they did and it is what is allowing the corporate socialist state to do what it is doing now.

    I apologize for my typos.

  58. Anna says:

    This girl is a total degenerate. I feel sorry for her only because she’s obviously entirely mentally deficient.

  59. Scott Blose says:

    All I have to say is this girl should check out Auschwitz. It seems that there is an agenda going on in this world and unfortunately my country-the USA to change what actually happened in history and to change the account of what happened to something totally false than what actually happened. There is an agenda of hate against the children of Israel-even though they are my he chosen people by YHWH. As a born again Christian, I stand with the children of Israel as they love and worship the one true and Living God that same as myself. I just want all the children of Israel to know that you are very much loved and prayed for by many in my country, especially Christians. Even though the moron that was elected as President in this country and many other people in our government are against you, they do not speak for all of us Americans. We stand by you showing God’s love and support and pray for you and your country

  60. William Nicholson says:

    We can’t help that she was in some way directed from the real truth . What I’m having a hard time with is, why her teacher gave her the grade, when SHE should have known the real truth .

  61. Lance R. says:

    Forgetting her confused understanding of history, let’s get serious about the quality of this poorly written paper. Typos and grammatical errors abound! I don’t know about everyone else, but when I was in high school, every such error dragged my grade down. This child should have been given a D for all of those little failures! The teacher needs a serious demotion.

  62. Zachary Turkheimer says:

    I know numerous holocaust survivors. I have toured Poland and seen Auschwitz I, and Auschwitz II- Birkenau, lodz ghetto memorial, Warsaw ghetto memorials, Treblinka memorial, yad vashem in Israel, and the United states Holocaust memorial museum in DC almost a dozen times. I have never read an article so falsely inaccurate in my entire life. I am disgusted at the comments by the individuals who agree with this ignorant young lady. The fact of the matter is that not only did 6 million jews die but also 5 million Pols, POWS, gypsies, homosexuals, and basically anyone who was against the Nazi regime.

    • Zachary Turkheimer says:

      Also, the Nazi’s were known for taking intricit records of their actions, especially in the camps. That is where majority of the data of 11 million people come from.

      • israelandstuffcom says:

        I know. I mentioned above how the first original estimate came from Dr. Wilhelm Hoettl, an Austrian-born official in the Third Reich and a trained historian who served in a number of senior SS positions.

        The abundance of proof is so overwhelming, the fact that many refuse to accept it must come from some sinister motivation. EVERY one of the ‘skeptical’ folks who refuse to accept it can spin it any way they like, but fact is, WE ALL see them for the antisemitic trailer-trash they are.

        All they need to do to be convinced, is go to Poland where they can see a wealth of original Nazi evidence with their own eyes.

  63. Sowmya says:

    While I understand everyone is entitled to their opinion, writing and publishing this essay was an inconsiderate and ignorant action on Jazzy’s part. Despite being many years ago, the Holocaust is still an event that is mourned and remembered by people in present day. It’s disrespectful to diminish people’s feelings and claim that the pain they’ve felt and suffered over the years is nothing but a hoax. What if someone you loved dearly passed away and others were saying that the death of your loved one is a lie? If Jazzy wants to believe that the Holocaust is a hoax, then so be it. I just don’t think it’s fair for the people who have been affected by the Holocaust to be questioned for what they went through.
    Also, one last thing…this really isn’t about censorship. I’m all for being able to express your feelings and thoughts but there’s a fine line between expressing your views on a subject and ignorantly dismissing other people’s views and feelings.
    (Also, Urban dictionary is not the most reliable source in my opinion!)

    • israelandstuffcom says:

      How much patience would you have when folks try and convince you the U.S. never sent astronauts into space? Since you can’t actually verify any of the rockets launched into space had folks in them, or the landing crafts weren’t actually placed into sea for the US Navy to retrieve, with astronauts inside, how do you convince them? They tell you all the pictures were ‘Hollywood effects’ etc. They say NASA is really the CIA. No gov’t evidence is reliable in their opinion…..so, do you ” ignorantly dismissing other people’s views”, knowing full well, they are wrong?

      The difference between the above example and the Holocaust is, as you pointed out, is emotional. My Mom was Hitler’s ‘guest’ at Auschwitz, my Dad was the one survivor from his entire extended family in Poland. Their stories, backed by what I saw with my own eyes in Poland, makes it impossible for me to remain ‘gentleman-like’ after the 3rd or 4th ‘denier’ spews his shit, based on sources that no western university would accept.

  64. don't worry about it says:

    The fact that people think that this horrible event did not happen is mind boggling. Knowing first hand that my entire family hid from the Nazis and half of them died to these monsters. There is proof and survivors of this tragic event. If you don’t believe me, look at the tattoos on their arms. I am disgusted that I live in a world where people think this is a myth. You should be ashamed, people lost their lives and were running for years. My grandparents hid in kitchen cabinets to escape the horror.

    • Phillip Pasmanick says:

      No one denies a ‘Holocaust’. What is denied about the Holocaust is the ‘6,000,000’ figure, they say past European census, of total Jewish population, and post-WWII numbers makes the figure unrealistic. Furthermore, they argue that the lack of absolute forensic evidence of Jewish deaths from poisoning, they argue the million or so Jewish deaths were from disease. The fact that the bodies went directly from the ‘showers to the ovens’, is irrelevant in their arguments.

      The least bright among them argue whether there were ever crematoriums, or gas chambers,…. even though Nazi produced films, photographs and tons of Nazi documents prove there were, and were working ‘overtime’.

  65. Mitzi Bokolas says:

    My dad would wake from sleep screaming like nothing I have ever heard. I would ask him, “why Dad”, his reply.” I was getting butted in the head with the German Guards Rifle”. “I watched them push my mother and baby sister into the gas chamber”. I asked,”then what?” He replied “I never saw them again until I was made to bury their bodies in a public pit with many many others

  66. Tara says:

    I would just like to say this article is shameful. I am all for sharing your opinions and being respectful toward others, but this was just too far. The fact that in the video the girl was giggling and laughing, looking off into the distance and claiming she got all information from her “uncle” is disgraceful. You have no idea what you are talking about, and urban dictionary along with an uncle is certainly not a reliable source whatsoever. You literally just quoted the sites with no actual evidence or proof. Again, I am all for people sharing their views, but next time maybe research the topic? even a little? I can tell you are severely undereducated about this subject as in the video you repeat like a machine what you read on the sites. The fact your teacher gave you an A is not what bothers me, if you wrote a good arguable essay about this subject it would be fine, that is your opinion and you’re entitled to it. But the fact you used urban dictionary and just simply quoted them with NO PROOf, i repeat next time please have certified articles and sources instead of quoting what a random website says. It is laughable. ALso, your points are weak. Cindy WIlson makes a great point on here when she comments that until she gets actual evidence she is going to believe the real evidence, monuments, and GAS CHAMBERS that are STILL existing. HOw can you not believe the countless stories people tell of loading JEWS into gas chambers and then burning them afterwards…maybe that is why THERE WERE NO AUTOPSIES. its a little hard to find the cause of death of a pile of ash. I feel bad she has this horrible idea in her head and was even praised by the teacher 🙁
    AGAIN, I’m not bashing this idea (although i do not agree with it) I’m saying the evidence was horrible, she didn’t deserve an A, and she seems completely uneducated on this seemingly 10 minute paper. PLease use better sources next time.

  67. seth richards says:

    First, this nitwit of a teenager has no idea as to the documentation that exists. second, there would never be any bodies for the Red Cross to examine that dies in the ovens…they’re burned beyond recognition and thereby not identifiable. Third, starvation to the degree which was seen in the films and newsreels does not occur over a few weeks or months but much longer. Fourth, Both the teacher and the Board of education should be fired on the spot for actually believing this drivel which lacks accurate documentation.

  68. Joy Wolfe says:

    Surely the best evidence is that of living survivors If this kind of thing is happening when some are still alive I hate to think how these stories will multiply and go unchallenged when there are no more living survivors. Sadly some of the comments on this piece really make me despair. How can people be so blind?

  69. simcha says:

    too bad this girl’s birth wasn’t a hoax

  70. Mitch says:

    I am almost 50 years old and when I was 15 there were Holocaust deniers and for the most part, they were hateful people who looked for loopholes about logistics, just like this 15 year old girl. The true research paper the 15 year old girl should have written was the “Unpublished History of Antisemitsim that lead to the Holocaust” – Why isn’t she concerned about how entire families were rounded up and starved and tortured to death just because they were born Jewish? The fact is, Mans Inhumanity to Man did not end or begin with the Holocaust but, we must try and live in a better world that will one day be free of such demonically hatred people. I wish beyond words can say that this 15 year old girl would write a paper that inspired people to never have another Holocaust against anyone! In the future, I hope the people of the earth put as much effort into saving lives as they have in murdering lives. I want to see the youth of the world write research papers on how we can all get along in peace and prosperity and feed the hungry and help the needy and preserve our history as it was so, we can never repeat the negative cycle that every youthful generation must learn for themselves. “Live long and prosper.”

  71. David says:

    I do not fault this girl, she is being told to use urban dictionary as a source and given an A. The people poisoning this girl’s mind are awful animals who should not be allowed to work with children!

  72. Mariana Belfer says:

    Is there a way to communicate with her school’s principal?

  73. Elad Stern says:

    I find there are many points of logical fallacy in the reality as it is perceived in the quoted essay above. When a child is born and raised without a father, the identity of the father may be argued, but from the mother’s account the identity of the father can be recognized.
    Therefore, to ask a single person about the number of holocaust deaths by the Nazis, is not the real method to ensure knowledge about the number of people killed. Rather, in Yad Vashem, the Israeli center for Holocaust research, each person who survived the holocaust has been asked about his or her relatives or intimate friends who helped them, and their fate when they died.
    Since this knowledge consists of actual intimate memories and their details, that bear resemblance to each other, when all names remembered by actual survivors who report first-person about the horror, when they were put together, the number of reports of people missing neared 6,000,000. This method is far more reliable than empirical research using limited sense perception measurements, which any PHD (Philosophy Doctor)’s mind should know to be error-prone, as philosophers as ancient as Pre-Socratic ones affirm and demand.
    Another issue is the expectation that the growth of worldwide Jewish population should be more or less linear, in a way that cannot compensate for the loss of so many, in the so-called apparent statistics. This line of thought does not acknowledge the 20th century’s major breakthroughs in medicine and hygiene, and the science of vaccinations and industrial produce of food and clothing in unprecedented rates. This have had an impact on the growth of the entire world’s population, that caused it to double itself several times during several decades, whereas in previous centuries it took several centuries to achieve the same rate of growth. Technological as well as social circumstances affect the willingness to bring more children to the world, as well as prevent diseases that stroke during infancy. Therefore, the growth of the entire population of the world should be compared, to that of the Jewish population following the holocaust. In fact, as the end of the holocaust marks the end of an era of persecution for the Jewish families worldwide, it is expected that together with worldwide advances that cause the population to multiply, the rate of growth among Jewish families should be unprecedented as well, after the holocaust years along with that of the rest of the world.
    This article tries to free German SS officers from responsibility to the lives and deaths of Jews, but it is recorded that the caloric assignment was several thousands for a German soldier in Poland, a little more than is necessary to keep body and soul together (about 1,200) for Polish men, and only a few hundred, much less than is agreed upon by all nutrition specialists around the world, as a bare minimum for keeping life functions together. Such is known today to cause gradual erosion of the body, susceptibility to disease, especially among those who work hard who should give back lost proteins and minerals to the body to compensate for muscle work. The poor nutrition reported in the camps (only very thin water-like soup for the entire day, peas at the bottom dealt only very exceptionally, as Victor Frankel reports the rare case he made one guard happy with singing one day, some common reactions were the cutting down of food for the entire day) fitted the German army’s ongoing letters communicated, that gave all possible commodities to German soldiers, and the least of what can be expected to the Jews.
    Survival became a business only few could manage, sometimes by outreaching others’ slice of bread before it vanishes, with unparalleled bodily weakness known and felt by everyone, that does not match the amount of physical toil they were forced to take by the German officers, having been driven away from their positions in parliament, in business organizations, in culture and practically every field of society by the Nazi party who suspected every citizen’s blood, and left practically no place for freedom of expression and speech, save and except the propaganda that the National Socialist party desired to promote in song and dance and every show of so-called culture, which had one particular binding factor and that is the overt loyalty to the Nazi party and its so-called racially pure leaders (save Hitler and several others, who did not fit the picture of the “perfect race” they took as the typical North European features).
    To conclude, a systematic driving away from social positions on a racial basis or bias, without valuing the contribution of those men, is what brought the health and collapse of bodily systems in great masses of population, even though all were willing to struggle one moment after another, working hard with no visible profit but avoiding certain death, the cause of diseases such as Typhus being spread among those who went through the holocaust. Extreme measures needed to be taken just to avoid disease, total loss of working capacity, and being reprimanded by the Nazi camp guards who were willing to kill anyone simply for talking with another, after tagging that person negatively in cooperation. The amount of stress, being at a loss in the ability to work one’s own means and contribute to society, the lack of replenishing facilities given to the German soldiers but not to the Jewish prisoners, would bring anyone to total collapse, unless he showed extraordinary features for survival, and such are written and documented in reports by actual survivors, which life favored over their peers.
    To ignore one thing as causing the other, stating only surface facts that is not a sign of the work of sincere scientific research, which should aim to extract more foundational conclusions to bring an understanding of processes that lie behind phenomena of interest. The study of history should be able to draw conclusions for generations to come, while the reasoning of one layer of cause with another, should go deeper into the cause of all causes that is the beginning and end of all human endeavor.

  74. C Sullivan says:

    And above all else, if you don’t believe any “external” sources of information, how about the Nazis themselves? The ITS Archive at Bad Arolsen – https://www.its-arolsen.org/en/ is the archive of the Nazis’ records of all the people they persecuted and put into camps – I would think it becomes impossible to ignore a reality when it is documented in detail BY THE VERY PEOPLE WHO DID IT.

    Add the notes from the Wansee Conference, and you have proof of intent, methodology, planning, logistics, and execution – all from the people who did it.

    I have been privileged to have met a few Shoah survivors…seeing those numbers tattooed onto their arms was the most powerful experiences in my life.

    I am not angry at this child..I pity her.

  75. Fritz Kohlhaas says:

    This proves that vicious anti-Semitism is being taught by leftist teachers in schools and universities! Wake up people! The vicious and violent Left is taking over!

  76. Do we know the school district? The principal? The teacher that gave her an A? Because all of them need to have their asses handed to them on a plate, and then they need to be marched, without food or water, however long, to the nearest Holocaust memorial and learn the facts. How appalling. The world is truly forgetting. I am sickened.

  77. Dotsy Maher says:

    This ignoramous upset me SO badly….this country MUST institute REAL education again before anymore children become babbling idiots in service of the NWO!

  78. solange silverman says:

    If anyone said that in front of me, I would absolutely lose it! She is beyond stupid. Her teachers are enablers. She should have been flunked and sent to see the principal. Instead, she gets an “A!?!” The teachers and school also need to be held accountable. I am furious. I would not call this freedom of speech, just getting away with being dumb, ignorant and hateful.

  79. Dale Lynn Franks says:

    Her fictional tale is just that, fiction. I would have failed her on her grammar and spelling first. She rambles on and shares the same information in repeated paragraphs. The teacher should be relieved of her job and the student should get tutoring on her English grammar skills.

  80. Rachel Bass says:

    I honesty can not believe I live in a world where the denial of one of the greatest and most targic events in our history can be denied. I’m seriously disgusted and ashamed that people actually believe the holocaust never happened. #neverforget

  81. Jack says:

    This young lady is several generations and a continent removed from the events that she so blithely reports on. The “Indoctrination” is not her fault, it’s the fault of the instructor. I’m sure that it isn’t coincidence that many of the survivors are gone, infirm and unable to recount their stories, as if the younger generation cares by what she has written. The accounts, photos, histories, and even former Nazi’s have confirmed the events. Only those too bent on an angle of hatred of the Jewish people can put forth such a scandalous account of lies. Again, she is so young as to know nothing, but her head is filled by someone else.

  82. Dave says:

    She needs to visit the concentration camps in germany. Seeing is believing.

  83. Mike Harrison says:

    “But remember she is only 15” “The parents aren’t responsible”
    “I can’t believe the “witch hunt” is toward a young girl and the teacher”,
    ITS ALL EXCREMENT – So then leave the girl alone – leave the teacher alone and continue to allow parents and teachers be ‘NON Teachers’ and ‘NON Parents.’ The simple fact is the INTERNET is NOT a reliable place. We have institutions called ‘Libraries’ But no one wants to take time to visit the Library anymore. No one wants to ‘fact check’ their children’s school projects. No one wants to be a real parent anymore – no one wants to be a real teacher anymore. This is the generation we’re left with. ‘God Help Us’

Leave a comment

Leave a Reply

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.