Kiwi peace activist caught lying to Israeli Security, then exiled!

Thomson, “I felt humiliated & ashamed. Eventually it seemed to me that he had found something out & knew that I had lied about something.”

By Bevan Hurley @BevanHurleyHoS


A peace activist was detained for 48 hours before being sent back to New Zealand for trying to enter Israel on a tourist visa.

Amy Thomson - Photo  Graeme Brown

Amy Thomson – Photo: Graeme Brown

Amy Thomson, 26, was held at Ben Gurion Airport in Tel Aviv on February 26. She tried to enter the country for a three-month voluntary internship at a non-government organisation promoting peace.

Thomson said the Israel Palestinian Centre for Research and Information told her she should claim to be a tourist.

Suspicions were raised when Israeli immigration authorities saw she had recently visited Lebanon, which is in ongoing conflict with Israel.

The Palmerston North student was ordered to hand over her mobile phone. After refusing to give up her Hotmail account password, she believed her email account may have been hacked.

Thomson was questioned for eight hours about her visit to Israel, who she knew, and her intentions.

She said they asked if she knew Arabic because of her Lebanon visit.

“I said there hadn’t been enough time to learn it, given I was there for only three weeks.

“A couple of hours later I was summoned by a new guy who said I think something about being security and intelligence. He asked me a lot of the same questions and grilled me about who I know there.

“He demanded that I tell him about everyone I knew in Israel. It was awful knowing that I may have compromised others working for the peace organisation.”

One interrogator mockingly congratulated her for winning a $500 prize for an essay she had written on Iranian politics which appeared on the Massey University website.

“I felt humiliated and ashamed. Eventually it seemed to me that he had found something out and knew that I had lied about something.”

Exhausted, after a 24 hour flight and 12 hours questioning, Thomson admitted that she was to work for a non-governmental organisation.

She was transferred to a detention centre and held with other detainees for 36 hours.

Her belongings were confiscated except for an electronic book reader. She was allowed one phone call to the nearest embassy in Turkey.

She said she regretted not being honest but it was a valuable experience.

“I know what it’s like for the Palestinians to deal with what they deal with every single day.”

The centre said it advised interns to travel on tourist visas as they could not get volunteer visas from Israel.

Thomson said the organisation was very apologetic. They said their interns had never been detained.

Thomson was banned from Israel for 10 years.


View original New Zealand Herald publication at:


  1. Gill says:

    Tragic. Youth need to engage but not by lying.

  2. Dafna Yee says:

    99% (and I’m not exaggerating!) of so-called “peace” organizations and NGO’s are in reality anti-Israel groups. If you want a partial list (about 300), go to

  3. Me says:

    : An interesting irony here is that while she was not allowed into Israel to work with a pro-Pal NGO and is propagandizing the result of her lies to the Israeli immigration…Israel has dozens, if not hundreds of these peace groups.

    How many in the West Bank or Gaza…?

    0. That’s right. 0. None. While there are lots of international NGOs that work in these areas, there’s not one ACTUAL peace-related NGO. Why? Because the Pals don’t want peace…? Not exactly. It’s because any Pal that wanted to start a peace group with Israel would find themselves in big, big trouble.

    So, she can go on and on about how terrible Israel is for kicking her out after being busted in a lie, but the if only of her situation – Having to go to Israel INSTEAD of the West Bank to work for a peace group- is not lost on the rest of us.

Leave a comment

Leave a Reply

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.