Done Deal: Israel signs new MoU for more German Dolphin class submarines

This version of Memorandum of Understanding enables Germany to withdraw if developments on corruption case in Israel shows cause, and allows Israel to purchase another 3 Dolphins, in addition to the 6 already acquired.

By Ronen Bergman


Germany approved a secret Memorandum of Understanding Thursday night with Israel which will see the latter purchase three more Dolphin submarines, on top of the six already previously acquired, Yedioth Ahronoth has learned.

Israel navy Dolphine class sub. – Photo: IDF Spokesperson’s Unit

The MoU underwent several changes in the last week following pressure exerted by senior German officials who sought to create a framework which would enable Germany to easily pull out of the deal in accordance with developments relating to the ongoing investigation into the submarine scandal investigation, also known as Case 3000.

While the final deal may be signed in an official ceremony, the two countries may simply exchange diplomatic communications.

According to the latest version of the MoU, Israel will purchase three more submarines in Germany, in addition to the five that already docked on Israel’s shores and the sixth that is currently being assembled at an overall cost of 2 billion euros.

The German government will be required to transfer half a billion euros to finance the deal.

Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu’s desire to see the deal pushed through was stymied by fierce opposition voiced by defense officials when the Defense Ministry was headed by Moshe Ya’alon.

ex-Minister Moshe Ya’alon, (left) – Photo: Ariel Hermoni/Defense Ministry spokesman

Netanyahu continued to advocate for the deal to be pushed through for another three submarines and for the signing of the MoU that would anchor German support for its implementation.

Under different political circumstances, Netanyahu has argued, Chancellor Merkel may not be in a position to lend the support of her government or offer her signature.

On the other hand, the most vociferous opponent of the deal, Ya’alon, has argued that Israel has no need for three more submarines, and that they should only be purchased a few years down the line when those currently moored in Israel’s naval bases are approaching the end of their operational functionality.

With a major gulf dividing the two, many in the political establishment believe it accounted for Netanyahu’s relatively sudden decision to give Ya’alon the boot in 2016, clearing the way for Avigdor Lieberman to head the Defense Ministry.

PM Benjamin Netanyahu with Israel’s Defense Minister Avigdor Lieberman in Jerusalem. – Photo: Amos Ben Gershom/GPO

Convincing Merkel to climb on board with the deal proved no easy task, and responsibility for nudging her into inking the deal was largely assigned to President Reuven Rivlin.

With the launching of Case 3000, the German government became increasingly skeptical about becoming entangled in any further involvement and announced it was loath to put pen to paper.

For this reason, Merkel’s former advisor, Christoph Heusgen, instructed that the agreement be frozen against Israel’s will in order to enable Germany to consider withdrawing altogether from the deal in the event that it emerged that previous acquisition of the submarines was indeed scandal-ridden.

The MoU was supposed to have been signed by the Israeli ambassador to Germany, Yakov Hadas-Handelsman, but was indefinitely put on the back burner.

Berlin continued to ask that Israel keep it abreast of developments in the investigation, a request that prompted Jerusalem to convene a special forum on the matter under the direction of the Justice Ministry.

The forum concluded that despite the mounting evidence that corruption had sullied the previous deal—which was spearheaded by now-state witness Miki Ganor who worked as an Israeli representative for the submarine manufacturer ThyssenKrupp—”the corruption did not fall on the root of the deal.”

In effect, the conclusion determined that the decision-making process, neither on Germany nor Israel, had been influenced by corruption, thereby convincing Merkel that she could now proceed.


View original Ynet publication at:,7340,L-3083,00.html